April 21, 2000
| Honorable Jon Kyl United States Senate 724 Hart Senate Office Building Washington, D.C. 20510 |
Honorable Dianne Feinstein United States Senate 331 Hart Senate Office Building Washington, D.C. 20510 |
Dear Senators Kyl and Feinstein:
We are writing to express our strong and unequivocal support for your efforts to pass S. J. Res. 3, the proposed Crime Victims' Rights Amendment, and send it on to the States for ratification.
As Attorneys General from diverse regions and populations in our nation, we continue to see a common denominator in the treatment of crime victims throughout the country. Despite the best intentions of our laws, too often crime victims are still denied basic rights to fair treatment and due process that should be the birthright of every citizen who seeks justice through our courts. We are convinced that statutory protections are not enough; only a federal constitutional amendment will be sufficient to change the culture of our legal system.
The rights you propose in S. J. Res. 3 are moderate, fair, and yet profound. They will extend to crime victims a meaningful opportunity to participate in each critical stage of their cases. At the same time, they will not infringe on the fundamental rights of those accused or convicted of offenses. Neither will these rights interefer with the proper functioning of law enforcement. Attorney General Reno spoke for many of us in law enforcement when she noted,
| [T]he President and I have concluded that a victims' rights amendment would benefit not only crime victims but also law enforcement. To operate effectively, the criminal justice system relies on victims to report crimes committed against them, to cooperate with the law enforcement authorities invstigating those crimes, and to provide evidence at trial. Victims will be that much more willing to participate in this process if they perceive that we are striving to treat them with respect and to recognize their central place in any prosecution. |
Some have argued that federal constitutional rights for victims will infringe on important principles of federalism. We disagree. Each of our state criminal justice systems accommodates federal rights for defendants. To provide a similar floor of rights for victims is a matter of basic fairness.
Please share this letter with your colleagues so that they may know of our strong support for S. J. Res. 3.
Sincerely,
| Bill Pryor Attorney General of Alabama |
Janet Napolitano Attorney General of Arizona |
| Bill Lockyear Attorney General of California |
Ken Salazar Attorney General of Colorado |
| Richard Blumenthal Attorney General of Connecticut |
M. Jane Brady Attorney General of Delaware |
| Robert A. Butterworth Attorney General of Florida |
Thurbert E. Baker Attorney General of Georgia |
| Earl Anzai Attorney General of Hawaii |
Alan Lance Attorney General of Idaho |
| Jim Ryan Attorney General of Illinois |
Karen Freeman-Wilson Attorney General of Indiana |
| Carla J. Stovall Attorney General of Kansas |
Albert Benjamin Chandler III Attorney General of Kentucky |
| Andrew Ketterer Attorney General of Maine |
J. Joseph Curran Jr. Attorney General of Maryland |
| Jennifer Granholm Attorney General of Michigan |
Mike Hatch Attorney General of Minnesota |
| Mike Moore Attorney General of Mississippi |
Joseph P. Mazurek Attorney General of Montana |
| Don Stenberg Attorney General of Nebraska |
John Farmer Attorney General of New Jersey |
| Patricia Madrid Attorney General of New Mexico |
Michael F. Easley Attorney General of North Carolina |
| Betty D. Montgomery Attorney General of Ohio |
W.A. Drew Edmondson Attorney General of Oklahoma |
| Hardy Myers Attorney General of Oregon |
Mike Fisher Attorney General of Pennsylvania |
| Angel Rotge Sabat Attorney General of Puerto Rico |
Charlie Condon Attorney General of South Carolina |
| John Cornyn Attorney General of Texas |
Jan Graham Attorney General of Utah |
| Iver A. Stridiron Attorney General of the Virgin Islands |
Mark L. Earley Attorney General of Virginia |
| Christine O. Gergoire Attorney General of Washington |
Darrell V. McGraw Jr. Attorney General of West Virginia |
| James E. Doyle Attorney General of Wisconsin |
Gay Woodhouse Attorney General of Wyoming |
| Bruce Botelho Attorney General of Alaska |
|
cc: All United States Senators |